For the Record · Historical Legal Archive · 2016

Court Decision: New Property Owners May Face Inherited Debts

In January 2016, a Supreme Court of Appeal judgment raised serious concerns about historic municipal debt and the position of new property owners. The legal position was clarified by the Constitutional Court in August 2017.

2017

Important: the law did not remain where it stood in 2016.

This article records a real legal controversy as it was reported in February 2016. On 29 August 2017, the Constitutional Court ruled in Jordaan and Others that a new owner is not liable, after transfer, for the previous owner's debt by virtue of the charge under Section 118(3). The original warning and precautionary advice below therefore belong to their historical setting and must not be treated as a statement of the law today. Read the full account of our Jordaan case.

01 / The original news

A judgment that unsettled the property market.

When the Supreme Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 29 January 2016, it appeared that the municipality's security for historic debt could continue to burden a property even after registration in a new owner's name.

In City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v PJ Mitchell, the dispute arose from a property purchased at a sale in execution. After the purchaser paid the amount needed for the statutory clearance certificate, older municipal debt remained outstanding. The municipality claimed that Section 118(3) still secured that debt against the property despite the transfer.

The majority of the Supreme Court of Appeal accepted that the statutory charge was not extinguished by transfer. It considered the possibility that a municipality could, after satisfying applicable legal requirements, enforce that security against the property. A new owner could therefore face serious financial exposure without personally having incurred the underlying debt.

The concern was not merely an old account. It was the possibility that a property already transferred could remain exposed to a previous owner's municipal debt.

Historical court reference: City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v Mitchell (38/2015) [2016] ZASCA 1, particularly the majority judgment at paragraphs 20–26.

02 / Our position in February 2016

Why MDS challenged the consequences of historic municipal debt.

For purchasers, sellers, conveyancers and mortgage lenders, the possibility that historic municipal debt could affect a property after transfer raised questions of fairness, legal certainty and property security.

At the time, MDS publicly opposed the consequences of this interpretation. Our original article explained that other litigation in which we were involved raised constitutional questions that had not been determined in Mitchell. It also reported that those matters were scheduled to be heard in the North Gauteng High Court on 22 February 2016.

We believed it was fundamentally unfair for new owners to face the consequences of debts they had not incurred.

Our 2016 advice was framed by that immediate uncertainty. It urged participants in property transfers to scrutinise clearance debts and historic municipal amounts and, as a precaution, to have them settled before transfer. That was advice given in the pre-Jordaan legal climate, not an instruction to purchasers today to settle every previous owner's historical debt.

The mention of a proposed February 2016 hearing records what MDS reported at the time; the subsequent definitive Constitutional Court judgment is documented below. The Mitchell proceedings were separate from the later consolidated Jordaan, New Ventures and Livanos matters.

2016Mitchell judgment

29 January: the Supreme Court of Appeal's interpretation creates concern about a municipal charge surviving transfer.

2016Related challenges advance

MDS reports ongoing litigation over the constitutional consequences of enforcing old debts against new owners.

2017Constitutional Court clarification

29 August: the highest court declares that the Section 118(3) charge does not make a new owner liable for pre-transfer debt after transfer.

03 / The decisive 2017 judgment

Our Jordaan litigation helped settle the question.

On 29 August 2017, the Constitutional Court delivered its unanimous judgment in consolidated matters involving Jordaan, New Ventures Consulting & Services and Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v Livanos.

The Court rejected the interpretation under which the municipal charge continued to burden an innocent purchaser after transfer. It held that Section 118(3), correctly interpreted in its statutory, common-law and constitutional context, does not cause that charge to survive transfer.

Although the Court formally upheld the municipalities' appeals against the High Court's declaration that Section 118(3) was invalid, it did so because the section could be interpreted constitutionally. In substance, the property owners obtained the protection for which they had argued. Section 118(3) was not struck down.

What the Constitutional Court declared · 29 August 2017

“a new owner is not liable for debts arising before transfer from the charge upon the property under section 118(3)”.

Extract from the Court's order in Jordaan and Others [2017] ZACC 31, paragraph 81(3). Read the judgment.

The joined proceedings are an important part of the history of Municipal Debt Specialist and its predecessor, New Ventures Consulting & Services. They explain why MDS regarded the 2016 ruling as more than an abstract legal controversy and why the challenge was pursued. Explore the Livanos and New Ventures origin story.

04 / Understanding the difference today

A transferred property, a clearance certificate and an unpaid account are not the same issue.

The Constitutional Court's decision did not abolish municipal debt or the statutory clearance process. It clarified what happens to the Section 118(3) security when ownership changes.

Section 118(1)

Clearance before registration

The transfer process still requires the prescribed municipal clearance certificate. This concerns qualifying amounts that became due during the two years preceding the application. Other lawful transaction-related payment obligations must be considered separately.

Section 118(3)

The municipality's security

Section 118(3) continues to create a municipal charge and preference while property remains with the debtor. Under Jordaan, that charge cannot be used after transfer to make the new owner liable for debts arising before transfer.

Historical debts

Not automatically erased

Pre-transfer debts do not simply disappear because a property changes hands. A municipality's rights against the person who legally owes them must be considered separately, including prescription and other applicable legal rules.

Clearance figures

Accuracy remains essential

High or disputed clearance figures can still delay a transfer. The relevant figures must be assessed against the law and the actual account records rather than assuming every demand is correctly calculated or automatically payable.

For fuller explanations, see Section 118(1), (2) and (3) and Municipal Clearance Figures and Certificates.

05 / Read the court record

Two judgments. One important change in the legal position.

These are the primary sources for the 2016 alert and the later 2017 ruling. Both remain essential to understanding the history in its correct sequence.

Property transfers · Ekurhuleni

Facing high clearance figures today?

This article is part of our historical legal record. For a present-day property transfer in the City of Ekurhuleni, MDS can assess substantial municipal clearance figures to determine whether there may be lawful grounds to challenge or reduce the demand. The initial assessment is free and without obligation. Not every matter qualifies.