FOR THE RECORD / AN URGENT MESSAGE TO PROPERTY PRACTITIONERS
The municipal debt trap could be written into your Offer to Purchase.
A seller signs an Offer to Purchase. A conveyancing team requests clearance figures. An administrative selection produces a much lower, two-year figure. But was the seller’s wider municipal debt ever established — and did anyone explain what the lower figure actually means?
An instruction that looks harmless in a standard OTP can leave sellers misinformed, purchasers exposed to avoidable disputes, and property professionals dealing with the consequences.

01 / THE 30-SECOND BRIEFING
Could your agency’s standard OTP be creating an avoidable risk?
A standard Offer to Purchase may tell the transferring attorney to obtain a rates clearance certificate without clearly addressing the seller’s full, legally recoverable municipal liabilities. That gap can become a serious misunderstanding when reduced two-year figures are requested.
The wording
The signed OTP focuses on getting clearance, but leaves wider municipal liabilities and professional instructions unclear.
The smaller figure
A conveyancing secretary or appointed rates runner may obtain lower figures for the prescribed two-year certificate period.
The false reassurance
The seller assumes the higher debt was written off. The purchaser may encounter difficulties later, despite important legal protections.
The amount needed to obtain a clearance certificate is not necessarily the full amount reflected on the municipal account.
02 / THE ISSUE FEW PEOPLE LOOK FOR
The problem may start in the OTP — long before anyone requests figures.
Many standard Offers to Purchase simply instruct that a municipal clearance certificate must be obtained. That is an ordinary and lawful part of a property transfer. But if the parties intend that the seller’s complete, legally recoverable municipal arrears must also be dealt with, where does the agreement actually say so?
Does it direct the conveyancing team to establish the full account position? Does it explain how disputed charges will be reviewed, what the seller must settle, and what proof the purchaser can expect? And who must be alerted if the municipality issues a second, dramatically lower set of figures?
Without clear instructions, professionals can correctly perform an administrative step while the parties remain fundamentally mistaken about the financial outcome.

A click on the municipal system cannot correct an instruction that was never properly written into the agreement.
03 / THE ONE-CLICK CLEARANCE TRAP
One administrative choice. Two very different understandings of the debt.
In matters brought to MDS, we have seen how a seemingly routine selection on a municipal clearance system can create misplaced confidence for everyone relying on the figures.
Why the people handling the file may not see the danger.
Conveyancing secretaries perform much of the day-to-day administration within legal practices. In Ekurhuleni matters, MDS has encountered workflows where an earlier request is rejected or a narrower application is made through the municipal RCS process, resulting in figures relating to the prescribed two-year period.
When this produces an immediate reduction, the outcome can look like a successful concession or special write-off. It may be nothing of the kind. The underlying older charges may still appear on the account and require separate legal and factual assessment.
Some conveyancing firms outsource clearance applications to rates runners. That can be a legitimate administrative arrangement, but the same risk arises if nobody checks exactly which figures were requested, what they cover and what was communicated to the seller.
The responsibility is shared: proper OTP drafting, conveyancer oversight, transparent instructions to staff and service providers, and clear disclosure to the parties. This is a systems and communication problem, not a blanket accusation against conveyancing secretaries or rates runners.

A lower figure is not automatically a debt reduction.
Requesting Section 118(1) figures for the statutory clearance certificate is lawful. But a certificate-period calculation should never be presented or understood as confirmation that every older debt has been cancelled or paid. The actual account must be checked, and amounts that are incorrect, prescribed or otherwise not legally recoverable must not be treated as automatically payable.
04 / THE FALSE SENSE OF CLOSURE
“But my attorney gave me these figures.”
This is one of the most damaging misunderstandings MDS encounters: a property owner has been shown lower municipal figures through the transfer process and reasonably believes those figures represent everything owed.
THE CONVERSATION WE OFTEN FACE
When our assessment uncovers a materially larger account position, a seller may understandably question us rather than the earlier information. The problem is not that the attorney deliberately misled anyone. It may be that two different kinds of figures were never explained as such.
A seller should never be left to discover near registration — or after the property changes hands — that the figure they were given was only for a limited statutory period. If the OTP and the file instructions explain the distinction early, this avoidable confrontation becomes far less likely.
05 / THE GAP BETWEEN THE LAW AND REAL LIFE
The Court protected innocent purchasers. Why are some still facing old debt problems?
Our Jordaan Constitutional Court litigation established that a previous owner’s Section 118(3) statutory charge does not continue to burden an innocent purchaser after transfer. The law does not make that purchaser responsible merely because they became the new owner.
Yet MDS continues to encounter reports of new owners facing obstacles with municipal account opening, services or demands linked to an earlier owner’s unpaid amounts. At times municipal administration does not reflect the protection declared by the Court. Whether any specific demand or refusal is lawful requires examination of the facts, but the disruption to an innocent buyer can be very real.
The legal victory is vital; preventing the dispute is better. A carefully drafted OTP and a properly explained clearance process can help avoid sending the buyer into a dispute they should never have had to fight.

What the law says
An innocent purchaser does not inherit the previous owner’s statutory municipal charge merely by taking transfer. The original debtor may remain responsible for valid debts.
What MDS sees in practice
Some new owners still face confusing municipal demands or interruptions, even though those older liabilities are not theirs. Correcting the records can be costly, stressful and slow.
What the law protects and what someone experiences at a municipal counter do not always align. Good contract design anticipates that practical risk.
06 / WHO PAYS THE PRICE?
The consequences can reach everyone in the sale.
The seller
A painful surprise
The seller trusts the figures received through the attorney’s office, believes the account was resolved, then discovers legally recoverable arrears may remain.
The purchaser
The wrong person under pressure
A purchaser who did not incur old debts may still have to challenge account or service problems, despite the protection of the law.
The estate agent
The deal and relationships at risk
Registration and commission can be delayed while the parties argue over what they thought would be settled.
The conveyancer
A difficult explanation
The legal team must reconcile the signed OTP, work delegated to staff or rates runners, and the full municipal account position.
The bank or lender
Unplanned transaction risk
Finance, expected proceeds and registration schedules may be disrupted by unexpected account disputes.
The municipality
An unresolved collection problem
Older recoverable balances may remain outstanding even after a certificate has been issued for the prescribed period.
When property transfers are delayed, everyone waits. But the better place to prevent some of these disputes is before the Offer to Purchase is signed.
07 / A REQUEST TO DEALER PRINCIPALS AND PRINCIPAL AGENTS
A message every estate agent should take to their dealer principal.
Sellers and purchasers are entitled to rely on property professionals for guidance. Most buyers and sellers are not municipal-law specialists. The responsibility to improve the standard form and the workflow sits with the people who design and manage the transaction.

Eight questions every agency should ask.
A well-considered OTP need not become an intimidating legal document. It must, however, make the parties’ intentions about existing municipal debt clear enough for the conveyancing team to implement.
For the agency meeting: ask whether your current form covers only the certificate, or also clearly addresses older recoverable charges, disputed amounts, proof of settlement, and what happens if the parties cannot agree.
Invite your conveyancing attorney to explain how those provisions translate into the actual municipal clearance application and final transfer process.
Does the contract distinguish the certificate payment from other lawful municipal liabilities attributable to the seller’s ownership?
Is there a clear process for verifying and challenging incorrect, prescribed or otherwise unrecoverable charges before payment?
Does the file require appropriate statements, settlement confirmations and disclosure of material historic account issues—not just the certificate?
Do the agent, seller, purchaser, conveyancer and administration team understand the same obligation and escalation procedure?
Are the timing, responsibility for costs, possible retention arrangements and lawful next steps addressed by professionally drafted provisions?
Ask your agency leadership to have the wording reviewed and revised before it is reused across hundreds of transactions.
Are changes to municipal applications reviewed by the conveyancer and explained to the parties before anyone treats lower figures as a settlement?
Do their instructions require disclosure of the original figures, later two-year figures and any outstanding balances or uncertainties?
This is a discussion checklist, not a ready-to-sign contractual clause. Seller obligations, prescription, apportionment, agreed adjustments and dispute-resolution arrangements require transaction-specific professional drafting.
Change the OTP before it becomes a problem. Don't wait for a property transfer to go wrong.
08 / THE SAFER CONTRACTUAL OBJECTIVE
If the parties intend full lawful settlement, the OTP must say so.
An incomplete approach
“Obtain the clearance certificate.”
That may be all the OTP says, leaving other municipal liabilities and disputes unanswered.
In practice, everyone may incorrectly assume that once the certificate is issued, the whole account is settled.
A more protective approach
Deal with the whole lawful municipal position.
Have the appointed attorney draft instructions that reflect what the seller and purchaser actually agree: verification of the complete municipal position, responsibility for legally recoverable seller-period debt, treatment of disputes and required evidence before proceeds are released.
There must also be a way to challenge erroneous, prescribed or otherwise legally unrecoverable claims. Full transparency does not mean blindly paying every amount on a municipal statement.
An important distinction
The point is not that the law forces every seller to pay every historical amount claimed by a municipality in every transfer. The point is that the signed OTP should knowingly deal with the parties’ lawful obligations and any unresolved balances, rather than leaving everyone to assume the certificate is a full reconciliation.
09 / MISINFORMATION AND UNLAWFUL INTERVENTIONS
The wrong expectations also make people vulnerable to bad advice.
When nobody has verified the account, an unexpectedly high amount may tempt sellers to seek help from unverified intermediaries promising a miraculous adjustment or deletion.
Unauthorized changes, questionable payments or unexplained reductions can trigger disputes and, in some cases, account restrictions or investigations. We distinguish those practices from lawful review and corrections of municipal billing errors.
Do not allow a vague agreement or a tight deadline to push a property owner towards an unlawful shortcut.

10 / OUR FIRST-HAND AUTHORITY
We fought to protect new owners. Now the industry can help prevent the harm.
Municipal Debt Specialist’s history includes the New Ventures and Livanos litigation that formed part of our landmark Jordaan Constitutional Court judgment in 2017.
The judgment clarified protection for new owners. Even so, problems caused by unresolved historical accounts can persist in municipal administration. That gap between legal rights and lived reality is exactly why we are asking the property industry to act earlier.
Our call to estate agents and conveyancers is therefore straightforward: design the OTP and the instructions carefully at the outset. Solve problems early instead of relying on eventual litigation to put them right.

11 / FREE PRACTICAL RESOURCE
A three-minute guide for the people preparing or signing an OTP.
A concise MDS publication to take to an estate agency meeting, share with a dealer principal or discuss with your transferring attorney.

Free downloadable MDS publication
Offer to Purchase & Municipal Debt: The 3-Minute Risk Guide
Understand where the risk starts, why the clearance certificate may not settle older liabilities, and the questions property professionals should be asking before the agreement is signed.
Share the guide with your dealer principal, conveyancing attorney and office team before the next standard OTP is issued.
12 / WHEN A HIGH CLEARANCE FIGURE ALREADY EXISTS
Already received clearance figures? Check what those figures actually cover.

If an attorney’s office or rates runner has already supplied reduced figures, establish whether they represent only the two-year statutory certificate period or have accounted for the complete municipal position. Do this before the seller treats the number as a write-off or authorises a final settlement.
MDS focuses on eligible property-transfer municipal clearance matters, principally in Ekurhuleni. We examine the whole legally relevant position, including potentially incorrect charges, recoverability, prescription and numerous other variables informed by our experience.
Free initial assessment
Normally answered within one business day.
For straightforward accepted Ekurhuleni matters, specialist audits and lawful resolution work typically take approximately 5–10 business days where no complications arise. These are not guarantees; municipal and registration processes are separate.
13 / QUESTIONS PROPERTY PROFESSIONALS ASK
Frequently asked questions.
Is it wrong to ask a municipality for Section 118(1) clearance figures?
No. Obtaining figures sufficient for the prescribed clearance certificate is lawful. The problem is assuming that this also resolves every other valid municipal liability or failing to address the parties’ contractual obligations.
Should every OTP insist that all historic debt be paid before transfer?
Agencies should have an attorney consider how their standard agreements address all relevant legally due and recoverable seller-period liabilities, disputed charges, allocation of costs and appropriate settlement mechanisms. There is no one-size-fits-all clause, and disputed or unrecoverable claims should not simply be treated as payable.
What if our OTP only says the seller must obtain a clearance certificate?
Ask the agency’s appointed attorney to review whether the agreement also deals clearly with older municipal debt, the seller’s responsibilities and what proof must be supplied. Do this before reusing the form.
Are conveyancing secretaries responsible for the problem?
Not automatically. They may be carrying out an administrative task from the signed agreement and instructions. Clear drafting, professional supervision and a deliberate account-review process are necessary to prevent mistaken assumptions.
Does the Constitutional Court judgment mean old owner debts can be ignored?
No. Our Jordaan judgment protects the innocent new owner from the previous owner's Section 118(3) charge, but does not erase all legally recoverable debts owed by the seller.
Can buyers still encounter difficulties with municipal accounts after transfer?
Reports received by MDS indicate that administrative disputes or service-account difficulties sometimes occur despite the legal protection. The legality and correct response depend on the individual facts, but early attention to the OTP and account position can reduce avoidable uncertainty.
Can MDS rewrite our estate agency’s Offer to Purchase?
The agency’s appointed legal adviser should prepare or approve the binding wording of the OTP. MDS can raise awareness of the municipal-clearance risks and assess suitable high-clearance-figure matters; this publication is not a substitute for legal drafting.
What if we already have high Ekurhuleni clearance figures?
Use our dedicated free property-transfer assessment, preferably before accepting settlements or paying disputed amounts. We normally respond to the initial assessment within one business day. Acceptance and results are case-specific.
Why did our clearance figures suddenly become so much lower?
In some Ekurhuleni workflows a revised application can produce the figures needed for the statutory two-year clearance certificate. That does not, by itself, mean older billed amounts were forgiven. Ask what period the figures cover and have the whole account reviewed for legally recoverable amounts.
What if the seller says, “But my attorney gave me these figures”?
The figures may be authentic but limited in scope. Compare the full municipal statement, original and revised clearance figures and the instructions in the OTP. Explain the difference clearly and do not assume that every older charge is lawfully recoverable.
What if our firm uses an outsourced rates runner?
Outsourcing the application can be appropriate. The responsible conveyancer should nevertheless be able to establish what was requested, what changed, what documents were received and whether the full municipal position was explained to the parties.
A PROFESSIONAL CALL TO ACTION
Before your agency uses that OTP again, ask who the wording protects.
Does our agreement deal with the seller’s municipal debt — or only with getting the certificate?
Ask your appointed conveyancer to review the standard wording, the process for revised clearance figures and any rates-runner instructions. Sellers and buyers should know precisely what is — and is not — being settled. For eligible high-clearance-figure transfers in Ekurhuleni, MDS offers a free initial assessment.
This article is general information, not a formal legal opinion or a ready-made sale agreement. For broader guidance use our Free Clearance Help Desk.